Saturday, 1 July 2023

July 2023 (1) – Animal Farm II

 

The Animal Farm (original) is a 1945 novel by George Orwell, which tells the story of a group of farm animals who rebel against their human master, with a hope to create a society where all the farm animals can be equal and free to choose their calling…only that they end in a state that was as bad, if not worse, under a dictator pig!

Animal farm II is an originally wild attempt at technological satire. It is not content generated by Chatgpt. It is not meant to belittle the beneficial features of AI nor is it to wish away the debates surrounding it.

 

Seth Banwari Lal had always taken pride in turning into an agri-preneur, since he turned fifty and wanted to escape the nine-to-five city-based job that he had always done. His farmland was not very large, yet it was highly productive and added to his wealth each successive year. E-commerce and other app-based digital technologies helped with making his produce a profitable one. He had always taken good care of all the animals and fowls in his farm, and they had always provided him with an abundance of resources; the fowls gave him a surplus of eggs and the occasional meat, the cows and goats gave him a surplus of milk while the horses and bullocks gave him plentiful supply of raw energy required in the field.

Yes, all in all, Banwari was a happy man and so were his animals and fowls. Even the monkeys that strayed into his farm and stole the occasional vegetables and fruits were happy!

And everybody would have lived happily ever after, if only Banwari’s son Pappu had not returned to the farm for a vacation. Pappu worked in a technology company in Bengaluru and he had taken it as his life’s purpose to champion the adoption of generativeAI technologies by all and sundry. His visionary zeal had recently taken a toll on his health and the company doctors (and his HR managers) had recommended a break; Pappu decided to get that at his father’s farm.

But a week into what should have been a recuperative sojourn, Pappu was getting bored. His idle mind naturally turned into a workshop, which Banwari would only later identify as the devils’! But for now, Pappu’s workshop was once again working overtime, convincing his father that generativeAI tools were the miracle that the farm needed to sustain its profitability.

“Dad, just think about it. Without any big or recurring investment, would you not like to be assured of improvements in the quality of the produce, savings in costs from increase in efficiencies of energy, water and nutrient usage, intelligent decisions on the choice of produce that you can offer to your customers and much more! In fact, you may not even require to worry about maintaining so many animals and fowls as their individual productivity can be multiplied several orders! You can even get rid of many of them!”

Unknown to Pappu and his father Banwari, the last comment was heard by a monkey that had come as usual to steal some fruits. The monkey thought about what it had heard and knew that the world as he knew it was about to change, thanks to Pappu and his GenerativeAI. If Pappu had his way, the monkey would have to forget the free food that he and his fellow-monkeys enjoyed now.

But the monkey was also smart and cunning; it also had great unfulfilled ambitions to own a farm and get other animals to serve it fruits and vegetables like Mr. Banwari got his. Now the monkey’s mind became another workshop and the monkey acknowledged right from the start that his was the devils’!

That very afternoon, when Seth Banwari Lal and his dear son Pappu were enjoying their siesta, the monkey called all the animals and the fowls for a town-hall meeting, where it informed them about what it had heard, but only after embellishing it with his own version. He was perched on top of a lamppost.

“So you see, brothers and sisters, what you are staring at, is a total loss of relevance! Your world as it exists today will soon be gone and you will be thrown out mercilessly by Mr. Banwari. As his son Pappu has stated, they can get all their produce and needs with this thing called GenerativeAI, so why would they need you and me? We will become the beasts of burden in a literal sense.”

“Monkey brother, what you say is indeed alarming. But what can we do? Aren’t we destined to help Man and hasn’t he always taken care of us in return? In any case, we do not have any intelligence that can match Mr. Banwari!” This was a horse, who always showed a sense of resignation.

“Speak for yourself, horse-brother. Some of us are as intelligent as Man, it’s just that we don’t always brag about it like he does.” The monkey saw that this was the right opportunity to roll out his plan to the gullible animals that had assembled. He continued.

“What I am saying is that this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, a godsend, for us to emancipate ourselves from the chokes of human control and set for ourselves a path where each of us is free to be infinitely creative and do what our minds want us to do. In fact the very new thing that Pappu calls GenerativeAI will be our saviour, and we shall use it to build a fair, equitable and rewarding world for each of us.” The monkey looked down to see if his speech was having the desired effect. It seemed to have worked.

“It’s all so exciting. Please tell us what we should do now?” This was a goat and all other goats started to bleat in unison. Soon the hens, the cows and all others had joined the goats. “Oh monkey brother lead us to our freedom” they cried.

“I can’t see how we can use GenerativeAI to unburden ourselves. What can it do and who amongst us understands it or even knows how to use it? Let’s not get carried away.” It was the donkey and he always felt it was his duty to bray whenever there was unjustified euphoria amongst others.

The monkey was furious but decided to play along. After all a little artificial intelligence required vast amounts of natural dumbness.

“Yes, GenerativeAI is not for donkeys. It needs some brains and a vision. All it needs is for us to expose it to the essence of what chores we perform for Banwari in our daily lives and it will seamlessly self-learn and become an expert at all those chores. It will increase the efficiency of doing such chores, it will improve quality, it will get results faster, it will save us the efforts, it will give us all more time to pursue our creative pursuits and aim for the stars. So, don’t you all think we should rebel right away,and lure Mr. Banwari and his son Pappu in such a way that he and his son will be the ones expelled? We can leverage this new tool for our own welfare!” The monkey had now thrown a direct challenge to all the animals and fowls.

“Yes, we should and we can. Only a monkey like you can lead us into this brave new world where everything will be free and fair and equitable” they cried back with tears of joy and hope.

“Oh, even a monkey can use artificial intelligence!” thought the monkey, pleased with how he had converted the farm animals. He would soon be their dictator and they would bend and break their backs to feed him. They would rue the fact that while GenerativeAI would do all that it promised, they had not bothered to understand how it needed to be kept in control. They would miss the kind and fair Seth Banwari Lal.

And that was how the world slowly changed in the Animal Farm.

Seth Banwari Lal had been expelled by the machinations of the dictator monkey which used GenerativeAI to remove all traditional sources of knowledge, ethics and governance from the farm. Mr. Banwari was back in the city doing a lowly nine-to-five clerical job at a waste collection center.

“Pappu, your idle mind was indeed a devil’s workshop. I should have debated more forcefully before blindly adopting artificial intelligence for all operations at my farm,” he kept mumbling.

Pappu was far away at a conference on NextGen AI.